Reading through the Bible: day 55

Numbers 13 – 15

The problem of giants

The descendants of Anak are said to be Giants in Numbers 13:33, so what? The Bible has mentioned giants before, and will mention them again (Goliath). Well, that apparently the problem.

Some versions, like the RSV, use the word Nephilim. This is a problem, since it’s just a case of Lazy translating, but it also supports the bias that the Nephilim (giants) in Genesis are something supernatural, when another explanation is available. With the popular view of the Nephilim being half angel, and all the mysticism and speculation that comes with it, we forget that this is just a transliteration of a Hebrew word that means giant, or even bully. So ignoring poor translation policies, let’s just talk about giants and see if the complaint that is raised makes any sense.

The complaint is that all the giants mentioned in Genesos 6 would have to have died in the flood, so how do we find their descendants in Numbers? Easy, we don’t. Without hiding behind the Nephilim as a special kind of giant, there is no reason to believe that these giants were related to the earlier ones. Just like there is no reason to believe that all dwarves that exists today had dwarves as parents and will have dwarves for children. The largest man in the Guinness Book of Records, unsurprisingly had normal sized parents. So perhaps a guy called Anak was big, and so were many of his descendants, there’s no reason to believe that this meant that some giants survived the flood.

I was a little surprised to see this complaint raised on a prominent site of Biblical criticism, but apparently even the supposedly good sites are struggling for real complaints.

There are a couple of interesting things, like Hosea son of Nun being the Joshua of the book by the same name, here Moses changes his name. Also, provision is made for sinning in ignorance. A sacrifice is still required, which follows the modern legal idea of, “ignorance is not an excuse.”

What are your thoughts?


The reading through the Bible page is up to date again, please share it and get others reading their Bibles.

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “Reading through the Bible: day 55”

    1. Well, yes, the aliens traversed millions of light years of intergalactic space to have sex with a technologically, and most likely intellectually, inferior species.

      Unfortunately the History channel has to make money, and sensationalism makes money. Even more unfortunate is the fact that evangelists also need to make money, and they also use sensationalism to promote their wares.

What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s